![]() |
|
| FRONT PAGE - JULY 21, 1999 - JEFFERSON, GA |
|
Judges order county to create public defender's department Move stuns BOC; costs could top $200,000 BY ANGELA GARY A tug-of-war over how to handle indigent defense in Jackson County erupted Tuesday when the judicial circuit's three judges ordered the county to create a public defender's department. The yearly cost for such a department is estimated to be $200,000 or more. The Jackson County Board of Commissioners received a court order Tuesday from judges T. Penn McWhorter, Robert Adamson and David Motes requiring that the four-employee department be formed with operations to begin Jan. 1. The judges gave the BOC an August 3 deadline for notifying them if it will comply with the order. If the county refuses, the judges said they would proceed with creating a panel system for the county's indigent defense at a cost estimated to exceed $300,000 per year. The move comes following a decision by current public defender Donna Avans to not serve in the position again next year. Judge Motes had requested that a public defender's department be created during a budget hearing earlier this month, but the BOC was not receptive to the proposal. The board seemed to favor filling the open position instead of forming the new department. Tuesday's court order stunned county leaders, who indicated they might fight the action. BOC chairman Jerry Waddell said Wednesday morning that the county is having its attorney look into how to respond. The chairman also pointed out that the other counties in the Piedmont Judicial Circuit, Banks and Barrow, have not been likewise ordered to form a public defender's office. Each of those counties has one person serving, he said. "It just floored me that they would do that," said Waddell of the court order. "Barrow County's caseload is a lot heavier than ours and they are going to let them keep doing like we are doing. But they want us to start a new department." Waddell suggested that Banks, Barrow and Jackson might share one public defender's office and split the bill. "Maybe that's what we need to do instead of all three counties having one," he said. The court order was accompanied by a letter from Judge McWhorter outlining the need for the new department. He pointed out that new guidelines established by the Georgia Supreme Court raised the hourly rate paid to appointed attorneys and dramatically lowered the caseload limits for public defenders. "Had these limits been in effect in 1998, Jackson County would have had to contract with three full-time attorneys to meet the caseload guidelines," McWhorter wrote. "This, of course, would have tripled the cost of the program with no corresponding increase in state contribution." The judge said that Avans' caseload would "crush any ordinary attorney." "Hiring one attorney to attempt to replace Ms. Avans would not only be a disaster but also a violation of state guidelines," he said. The court order also calls for at least one public defender to be hired by Oct. 1 of this year. This concerns Waddell because there are no funds in this year's budget to cover this salary. "Where do they think we are going to get the money to do it the rest of the year?" he asked. "I just don't understand their thinking. I realize that Donna Avans is leaving, but she is not leaving until Dec. 31. It's not like we are going to be without someone." The public defender would serve a two-year term and would be paid at the same rate as a state-paid assistant district attorney of equivalent training and experience. This person would then hire the other employees, an assistant public defender, an investigator and a legal secretary or paralegal, and set up the office by Jan. 1. All of the staff members would be considered county employees and receive benefits provided by the county. The public defender serves all people found to be indigent who are accused of crimes in the Superior, State, Magistrate, Probate and Juvenile courts. This would not include death penalty cases. The order further states that if a dispute arises between the public defender's office and the county, the dispute will be referred to the chief judge of the Superior Court, whose decision will be final. |
The Jackson
Herald - Jefferson, Georgia
Telephone: (706) 367-5233 Fax: (706) 367-8056
Email
MainStreet ADVERTISING OR PRINTING
Email MainStreet NEWS
DEPARTMENTS
® Copyright 1999 MainStreet Newspapers, Inc. All rights reserved.